Why consultancies lose their best people at Senior Manager level

Rishi DuSodha is a Partner at InX, where he works with consulting firms on senior leadership hiring. Here he explains why the pressure to sell is pushing capable Senior Managers out of the profession, and what firms could do much earlier to prevent it.


Senior Manager retention is a persistent issue in consulting, and the usual explanations do not hold up. Why do firms lose some of their best people at this level? For many, it is not the workload, the clients or even the travel, but the growing expectation that they will start to sell.

The conversation I keep having

I have spoken to countless Senior Managers who describe the same tension, often in remarkably similar words: that they are not “salesy”, that they do not want to sell to their own network, or that they enjoy consulting but not business development. These are not people struggling with the craft. They are credible, capable consultants who have reached the point where the role changes shape, where delivery alone stops being enough and the firm begins asking for a skill they were never taught. Some quietly decide the next step is not worth taking, and remain at Senior Manager level, while others leave.

What the best Partners actually do

The irony is that the best Partners I know rarely see themselves as salespeople. They build relationships, solve problems, connect people and stay visible, and the work follows as a result. None of that resembles the version of selling that Senior Managers are trying to avoid. It looks much more like good consulting applied to a wider set of relationships, and the gap is that few firms ever make that connection explicit.

Why some people find it easier

I have always enjoyed networking, relationship building and solution selling, but I recognise that this comes more naturally to people who have been exposed to it from an early age. Not everyone has had that exposure, and there is no reason it should be a prerequisite for making Partner. That is why I believe firms carry a responsibility to teach business development much earlier in a career than most currently do.

Why business development training for consultants should start on day one

Consultancies invest heavily in building technical capability, with structured training, regular coaching and practical exposure on live work, all beginning in the first weeks of a career. Nobody expects a new Analyst to work out problem structuring alone. If business development received the same treatment from day one, through structured training, ongoing coaching and real exposure to client conversations, then by the time someone reached Senior Manager, building relationships and identifying opportunities would no longer be something to fear but simply part of how they work.

The commercial case

The firms that get this right will retain more of their future Directors and Partners and will almost certainly grow faster as well, because strong relationships outperform cold outreach in every market. A firm in which people build relationships as a matter of habit has a pipeline that does not depend on a handful of individuals carrying the commercial load.

There is a broader point here too. AI will change many aspects of consulting, but I am not convinced it will replace trust, relationships and human connection any time soon. If anything, those qualities become scarcer as other capabilities become easier to automate, which is a strong argument for investing in them earlier.

A question for the market

Have firms left business development training too late, or should we expect future leaders to work it out for themselves? I would be interested to hear where you stand.

TLDR

  • Consulting firms lose Senior Managers largely because the role begins to demand business development skills that the firm has never trained them to use.

  • The best Partners tend to build relationships, solve problems and stay visible rather than sell in the traditional sense, which means the skill can be taught as an extension of good consulting.

  • Firms that teach business development from the first weeks of a career, with the same structure they apply to technical skills, are likely to retain more future Directors and Partners and to grow faster.


How InX can help

InX works exclusively with private equity and professional services firms, supporting consulting practices with permanent and interim leadership hiring, team lift-outs and counsel on team composition and the wider talent market. To discuss how your own leadership pipeline is developing, get in touch with Rishi DuSodha or the wider InX team.

Next
Next

Women in Consulting: In conversation with Katharina Erfort, Principal at Inverto